+1(323)689-1506 support@essayhubmarket.com

Looking for help with an assignment? Connect with an assignment Expert Now!

Thompson does not believe all abortions are justifiable. In her mind, when is it not justifiable?

Probably the most significant article written in defense of abortion is Judith Jarvis Thompson’s famous “A Defense of Abortion” (Philosophy and Public Affairs 1, no. 1 [Fall 1971]: 57–66), written back in 1971 and reprinted many times since. Thompson’s most common method of argumentation is by analogy, and she applies this technique very effectively. Her most famous analogy is the “unplugging the violinist” analogy found in this article.   350 words

  1. While Thompson does not think the unborn is a person, she is willing to grant it for argument’s sake. Even if the unborn is a person, she still believes abortion is justifiable in at least some cases, especially when a woman becomes pregnant against her will (either through force, like rape, or just unintentionally, like through failure of birth control to work). Her “unplugging the violinist” analogy is designed to make her case. Do you think the analogy works? Why or why not? Is it analogous in relevant respects to a woman becoming pregnant against her will? If you do not think it works, where are the places it is disanalogous? (Note: In order to make her point, Thompson employs a number of scenarios that might first strike you as strange and unrealistic (like kidnapped violinists and people seed-pods). At first, you might react by dismissing these; however, try to understand the point behind the illustrations and not get caught up on their unlikelihood. At times, philosophers purposely use unrealistic scenarios to distance you from the real situation and to help you see important salient points they are making.)
  2. In section 4 of the article, Thompson discusses the argument from pro-lifers that, if a woman engages in sexual intercourse voluntarily but becomes pregnant against her will (either by not being careful or a failure of contraceptives), she is still responsible to carry the child to term, as she loses her right “to not have a child” by taking the risk of voluntarily having sex. This is sometimes referred to as the “if you play, then you pay” argument. Thompson argues that even in these cases a woman has not given her right away just because she voluntarily participated in sexual activity, and she uses the “burglar” and “people-seeds” analogies to argue her point. Do you think her argument succeeds? Why or why not? If not, in what ways are her analogies disanalogous?
  3. In section 7 of the article, Thompson raises the question of the special relationship between the fetus and the mother and asks if that relationship should play a part in maintaining an obligation to not have an abortion. One obviously recognizes that parents have an obligation to care for their children and not harm them. According to Thompson, when does that obligation begin? Do you think she argues this beginning point well? Do you think parenthood marks an important difference between pregnancy and the violinist illustration? Why or why not?
  4. Thompson does not believe all abortions are justifiable. In her mind, when is it not justifiable? Do you think she is being consistent here? Why or why not?

Get a Quick Quote

Approximately 250 words
Total price (USD) $: 10.99

Reviews from Clients who Ordered From Us:

Kate Hogan

They are my go to assignment helper and have been a great help. Thank you!

Sheena easton

I`ve been working with this website for over a year! Here`s what I liked the most about them. First, quality of writing (creative and with catchy titles).

Our Benefits

Get your essay writing needs completed by us and enjoy these and more benefits:


Whether you have a last minute discussion post due in a couple of hours or the last day in class and you totally forgot to work on that research paper, we always put everything aside to save your grade

Custom Essay

Our qualified team of experts have access to varied online library databases to help with recent and well researched tools that help in writing your paper to deliver a profound research that earns you a stellar grade

80+ Subjects

We do not turn down any type of work. We have qualified writers holding bachelors, graduate and Doctoral certificates matched with skill and expertise. Get help with homework acroos varied subject

Real Time Tracking

We have a user friendly interface to help you track the progress on your order from your client portal. Additionally, with each and every step, you will get notified on the status of your paper to give you an easy time to do other kinds of stuff

Order Our Custom Essay Writing Service

1. Making an Order Tip and Tricks

  • Choose the type of assignment, topic, subject, length, and deadline for your paper.
  • Indicate the following order parameters: service, chosen writer level, number of cited sources, and citation style.
  • Add your document or provide instructions for paper in a specific form.
Image showing step 1 of making an order
Image showing how to make payment for your order

2. Tips and Tricks for Choosing the Right Writer

  • Log in using your email address or your Facebook account.
  • A list of suitable writers will be offered to you. Before making a selection, you can read testimonials or engage in a Live Chat with authors.
  • Check your balance and, if necessary, add funds to your account. Here you will also find exclusive bargains.
  • Put money into the account of the chosen writer.

3. Tips and Tricks for Supervising the Writing Process

  • Get the chance to keep track of the process and connect with your writer.
  • If required, include updated instructions.
  • Have a conversation with your author.
Image showing how to supervise writing process
Image showing how to download your completed results

4. Tips and Tricks to Enjoy the Results

  • You will receive the paper. You have the option of requesting modifications if they are required. Before giving it back to the writer, make a list of the adjustments that need to be made.
  • Accept the paper and send the money to the author.
  • Rate your writer, submit your request, then sit back and enjoy the results.

How can we even make your school life easier with our services?

We always strive to provide the best techniques and skills that help your essay a stellar paper. We have achieved this through the years by offering features such as:

Progressive Delivery

Your order is assigned to a writer who delivere’s your bulk research projects in small chunks and making edits upon feedback from the professor

Native Writers

Our writers are varied across different coutnries such s Canada, Australia, U.K and the United States. Request a native speaker writer to help you ace that paper

Powerpoint slides & other visuals

Order a visual such as Powerpoint to better expound your research paper at $10 per slide including speaker notes

Top rated writers

Order from among the top 10 rated writers at no extra cost